Philadelphia Student Claims School Violated Privacy With Web Cams On School-Owned Laptops
The parents of Blake Robbins, a 15-year-old student at Harriton High School, an elite suburban Philadelphia public school in the Lower Merion School District, have filed a lawsuit alleging that the school district violated Robbins’ privacy rights when it activated the webcam in his school-issued laptop. In response, the school district does not deny that it has remotely activated laptop webcams in the past. However, the school professed that it only did so to "locate a laptop in the event it was reported lost, missing or stolen so that the laptop could be returned to the student."
According to the complaint, Robbins learned of the school’s alleged use of the webcam when an assistant principal at Harriton High School, Lindy Matsko, cited evidence taken from the webcam on Robbins’ computer in support of the school’s accusation that he was using drugs. The family claims that the items Matsko perceived as “drugs” were actually candy.
While one would anticipate that the federal claims of the lawsuit would receive similar treatment in the district courts, whether in Pennsylvania or here in Washington, had this case arisen in Washington it would have implicated some interesting aspects of Washington privacy law. Washington’s Privacy Act prohibits all persons from eavesdropping or recording confidential communications. The Act prohibits the interception of “private communication transmitted by telephone . . . or other device,” or “private conversation” without the prior consent of all parties to the communication.
